Study of Antiherpetic Efficiency of Phosphite of Acycloguanosine Ableto Over come the Barrier of Resistance to Acyclovir

Full Text

INTRODUCTION Infections caused by the herpes simplex virus (HSV) are widespread: from 50 to 95% of the world adult population possess antibodies to HSV-1, and 20-30% are carriers of HSV-2 by the age of 15-29 years, wherein the number of seropositive persons increases with age [1, 2]. After the initial infection, herpes viruses establish a lifelong latent infection with periodic recurrences. HSV can infect various organs and tissues, leading to a variety of clinical manifestations of the infection, including skin, the mucosas and eye lesions, and even generalized forms with damage to internal organs and CNS [3]. Therefore, it is important to have available dosage forms both for external use and systemic administration for the treatment of herpetic infections of various severities and localizations. For this purpose, nucleoside analogs are commonly used in medical practice. First of all, these are the known antiherpetic agents acyclovir (ACV, ACG, Zovirax, 9-[(2-hydroxyethoxy) methyl]-guanine) available either as 5% ointment, 5% cream or 3% ophthalmic ointment and in the form of tablets, 8% suspensions for internal use, lyophilized powder for infusion solution, and lyophilized powder for injection solution (GlaxoSmithKline group of companies and etc.). Moreover, first-line antiherpetic agents include penciclovir (PCV, 1% cream) and metabolic precursors of ACV and PCV: valine ester of ACV (Valtrex, tablets with a dosage of 250, 500, and 1000 mg) and famciclovir (Famvir, film-coated tablets, 125, 250, and 500 mg dosage forms). However, herpes viruses develop resistance to these drugs. The frequency of isolation of HSV with drug resistance in clinical practice depends on the immune status and ranges from 0.5% in immunocompetent patients to 2-36% in immunocompromised patients [4, 5]. There are cases when diseases with a severe clinical course (herpes pneumonia, meningoencephalitis, extensive mucocutaneous lesions, etc.), which can lead to the death of the patient, were associated with ACVresistant HSV variants [9-9]. HSV resistance to ACV is due to mutations in the UL23 gene encoding thymidine kinase (TK) and/or UL30 encoding DNA polymerase, with which is associated a mechanism of drug action. The first stage of ACV phosphorylation resulting in ACV monophosphate formation is catalyzed by viral TK, while the next two stages are catalyzed by host cell enzymes. ACV triphosphate (the active metabolite of ACV) inhibits viral DNA polymerase and, moreover, inhibits elongation through the mechanism of termination, being incorporated in the newly synthesized DNA chain [10]. Resistance of HSV clinical isolates to ACV is in 95% of the cases due to mutations in the UL23 gene, which, as a rule, lead to a loss or significant reduction in TK activity (96%). Mutants with altered substrate specificity to TK are much more rarely isolated (4% of all TK mutants) [11, 11]. It is important to note that due to the similarity between the mechanisms of ACV and PCV action, the resistance of HSV to these drugs has in most cases an overlapping profile, which leads to a reduction in the efficiency of the therapy using ACV, PCV or their metabolic precursors. Trisodium salt of phosphonoformic acid (PFA, foscarnet) is used in such cases in international practice [12, 13]. In addition, there is a positive experience of using CDV (cidofovir, Vistide) in the most severe cases when PFA also turned out to be ineffective [14]. These drugs are in most cases equally effective in inhibition of the reproduction of HSV variants both sensitive and resistant to ACV and PCV. Unfortunately, PFA and CDV are highly toxic and their use is prohibited in Russia. HSV mutants that share cross-resistance to ACV/PCV and PFA and/or CDV have been also described [15-17]. Therefore, the development of agents effective against HSV and preventing a recurrence of the disease is highly relevant. Phosphite of acycloguanosine (Hp-ACG, phosphonate of 9-[(2-hydroxyethoxy)methyl]-guanine) is an H-phosphonate derivative of ACG. We have shown earlier in an HSV-1 model that Hp-ACG exhibits antiviral activity both in vitro (Vero E6 cell culture) and in vivo (i.p. administration in infected mice). The drug is active not only against the HSV-1/L2 reference strain, but also against the ACV-resistant laboratory strain HSV-1/L2/R and resistant clinical isolates of HSV-1 (Avd and Sha), which have epidemic value [18-21]. Thus, Hp-ACG may be of interest to practical medicine as a drug that effectively suppresses the infection caused by ACV-sensitive and -resistant variants of HSV-1. In the present study, we have determined the efficiency of orally administered Hp-ACG in mice with a generalized herpes infection, as well as conducted a comparative study of the ointment formulation of Hp- ACG and ACV for the development of drugs for the treatment of a cutaneous herpes infection. EXPERIMENTAL SECTION Compounds Hp-ACG was synthesized at the V.A. Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, RAS. ACV (9-[(2-hydroxyethoxy) methyl]-guanine) (GlaxoSmithKline, USA/UK) was used as a reference drug. Viruses and cells HSV-1/L2 strain from the State Collection of viruses at the D.I. Ivanovsky Institute of Virology was used in this study. A line of Vero E6 cells (African Green Monkey Kidney Cells) was kindly provided by A.M. Butenko (D.I. Ivanovsky Institute of Virology, Ministry of Healthcare of the Russian Federation). Animals Agouti guinea pigs of 250 g weight (males) and BALB/c white mice weighing 8-9 g (males) were obtained from the nursery Stolbovaya Branch of the Russian Academy of Medical Sciences (Moskovskaya oblast, Chekhovskiy rayon, Stolbovaya pos.). The animals were healthy, and they had a veterinary certificate of quality and health. All procedures were carried out strictly in full compliance with the requirements stated in Rules of Work with the Use of Experimental Animals № 755 dated 08/12/1977. Cytotoxicity Cytotoxicity was evaluated in accordance with the conventional trypan blue exclusion method of cell staining [20, 21]. CTD50 was considered to be the substance concentration which ensured the death of 50% the cells after 72 h of incubation. Antiviral activity The antiviral activity of the compounds in vitro was assessed using the micromethod by their ability to protect infected cells from death by preventing the development of a virus-induced CPE in accordance with the method designed by De Clercq E. et al. [22] as we have previously described [20, 21]. A monolayer Vero E6 cell culture grown in plastic 96-well plates (Linbro, Flow laboratories, UK) was infected at a multiplicity of 0.1 PFU/cell; the duration of incubation was 48 hours at 370C. In the control viral CPE was developed to 95- 100%: i.e., it covered the entire monolayer of cells. Efficacy of the agent was quantitatively expressed as ID50 and ID95, concentrations of the compound that inhibit the development of virus-induced CPE by 50% and almost completely, respectively. Antiherpetic activity Antiherpetic activity of the compounds was studied on an experimental model of mice with a generalized infection. HSV-1/L2 adapted to mouse brain was used. Infectious material was introduced i.p. in a volume of 200 μl at a dose provoking the death of 95 or 50% of the animals in the infected, untreated control group. The infecting dose is specified for each experiment separately. The animals received the studied compounds dissolved in thrice-distilled water or saline i.p. or orally in a volume of 0.2 ml. Single doses of the compounds and the number of animals in the group are specified separately for each experiment. The compounds were administered twice daily for 5 days, and the first administration was 1 h after infection. The observation period was 21 days. The effectiveness of the drugs was evaluated based on their ability to protect the animals from death (survival rate compared to infected, untreated control group) and an increase in the MDD. For a maximum MDD has been accepted as 21 days (observation period). A total of 96 h after infection, when infectious titer reached a maximum value in the brain of the infected animals, three mice from each group were sacrificed. Brain and lungs were isolated and homogenized in Dounce homogenizer at a temperature of 40C, and a 10% suspension was prepared in saline, centrifuged at 5,000 rev/min and 40C for 10 min. Infectious titer of the virus was determined in the supernatant by plaque formation by titration in cell culture as described below. The efficacy of the drug was assessed by a reduction in infectious virus titer values in organ material from animals of the experimental group receiving the drug compared to the control (infected but not treated animals). In order to assess drug efficacy in an experimental cutaneous infection [23], viral material was applied with its subsequent rubbing on the scarified after depilation of skin areas of the guinea pigs of about 5 cm2. Viral titer was 7.87 lg PFU/ml. At 48 h after inoculation with HSV slight redness appeared on the infected surface , followed by treatment initiated with the application of ointment twice daily for 5 days. PEG 600 was used as a base for the preparation of the ointment. Infectious virus titer The value of infectious virus titer in vesicle fluid was determined by plaque formation assay as described below. Vesicular fluid intake was conducted 4 days after infection. Infectious virus titer was determined by plaque assay. The 24-hour culture of cells grown in 24-well plastic plates (Costar, USA) was infected with 10-fold dilutions of the virus. After 1 h, the cell monolayer was washed from non-adsorbed virus with saline, a coating medium (2 ml/well) was added, and the cells were incubated at 370C in 5% CO2 atmosphere. The overlay consisted of Eagle’s and 199 mediums (produced at the M.P. Chumakov Institute of Poliomyelitis and Viral Encephalitis RAMS, Russia) mixed at a ratio of 1 : 1 with 5% fetal bovine serum and 0.4% agarose (Sigma, USA). After 48 h, the overlay was removed, the infected cultures were fixed with 10% neutral formalin, stained with a 0.5% gentian violet solution, and the plaque number was counted [24]. Infectious titer T was calculated using the formula and expressed as lg PFU/ml, where PFU is the plaque forming unit. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION We have shown that Hp-ACG is equally effective in the selective inhibition of the reproduction of both ACV-sensitive and -resistant HSV strains, including laboratory strain HSV-1/L2/R and the clinical isolates Avd and Sha, which circulate in the human population and now are among the most frequent TK-negative/ deficient phenotypes in clinical practice [18, 19]. The corresponding data are shown in Table 1. Table 1 Antiviral activity of Hp-ACG and ACV in a Vero E6 cell culture [18, 19] Note. HSV-1/L2 - reference virus strain; HSV-1/L2/R - laboratory virus strain highly resistant to ACV; Avd and Sha - ACV-resistant clinical isolates of HSV-1. Multiplicity of infection - 0.1 PFU/cell. Duration of incubation - 48 h. The results of two independent experiments are presented. CTD50 for ACV and Hp-ACG equal > 400 and > 1000 μg/ml, respectively. SI was calculated as the ratio of CTD50 to ID50. The results obtained in vitro were confirmed in experiments in vivo on a model of experimental HSV infection in BALB/c white mice. Since the infection caused by the ACV-resistant HSV-1/L2/R variant was not lethal, the efficiency of Hp-ACG in i.p. administration was evaluated based on the influence on viral accumulation in the brain of the animals. It was demonstrated that the introduction of Hp-ACG (450 mg/kg, twice per day) led to a decrease of virus titer of 1.30 lg PFU/ml (from 3.31 ± 0.16 to 2.01 ± 0.11) of day 4. This result was close to the effect of Hp-ACG in similar conditions on the model of HSV-1 reference strain: virus titer decreased from 5.49 ± 0.25 to 4.01 ± 0.16 lg (mortality in the control in the latter case was 92.5%, mortality decreased to 67.5% in the experimental group, and MDD increased from 4.90 ± 0.75 to 10.25 ± 1.20) [18]. We have established a mechanism of resistance formation in HSV-1/L2/R, Avd, and Sha strains. HSV-1/L2/R and Sha strains contain mutations in the UL23 gene, which lead to R220H substitution in TK and, as a result, to a loss of enzyme activity. Such an enzyme is incapable of catalyzing the first step of ACV phosphorylation required for its conversion into active metabolite ACV triphosphate, which is capable of incorporating into a newly synthesized viral DNA chain and aborting its elongation through the mechanism of termination. Deletion deltaT66 was found in the UL23 gene of the Avd strain located in close vicinity to the ATP-binding site of the enzyme (amino acid residues 51-63), which may cause a decrease in ACV phosphorylation efficiency [20, 25]. The obtained results confirm that all the ACV-resistant HSV strains included in the study exhibit a TK-deficient phenotype and allow one to suggest that mutations in the nucleoside binding site and ATP-binding center do not substantially affect the metabolic conversions of Hp-ACG to monophosphate of ACV, which, like ACV, is further converted into diand triphosphate of ACV. However, this conversion likely occurs through an alternative pathway by passing the stage of degradation of Hp-ACG to ACV [21]. The development of herpes encephalitis is known to be the cause of death in animals with a generalized herpes infection, and in order to exhibit antiviral activity, the drug has to overcome the blood-brain barrier and enter the brain of the infected animals. Apparently, i.p. introduction of Hp-ACG results in a concentration of the drug into the animal brain that can effectively inhibit virus reproduction. However, the bioavailability of drugs upon per os administration is lower than in the case of i.p. or intravenous administration and the drug dosage should be increased in order to preserve its antiviral efficacy. For example, the bioavailability of ACV when administered orally does not exceed 10-20%. The maximum concentration of ACV in blood serum upon per os administration of 200 mg of the drug is 0.4-0.8 μg/ml. Intravenous administration of a standard dose (5 mg/kg, three times a day) provides a significantly greater concentration of ACV in serum; about 9.8 mg/ml [26]. In a series of cases, oral administration fails to be effective. For instance, because of the extremely low bioavailability of CDV upon per os administration ( < 5%), the drug is administered only intravenously [27]. The bioavailability of PCV upon oral administration is also very low: 5% [28]. In this regard, PCV is used only in the form of its metabolic precursor, famciclovir, for oral administration. Structural modifications allow one to increase the absolute bioavailability of PCV from famciclovir up to 77% after a single oral administration [29]. Therefore, having continued the logical development of the research we conducted on the antiherpetic activity of Hp-ACG in vitro and in vivo [18, 19], we studied the ability of Hp-ACG to protect mice with an experimental generalized infection caused by HSV-1 from death upon oral administration. The pathogenicity of ACV-resistant HSV variants containing mutations in the TK gene is known to be defined by their phenotype, since it depends on the level of TK activity. Experiments on laboratory animals have shown that TK-negative and TK-deficient strains usually exhibit a substantially reduced virulence or are avirulent; i.e., incapable of causing lethal infection in laboratory animals and manifesting as zosteriform [30, 31]. As it has been noted, the ACV-resistant strains of HSV-1/L2/R, Avd and Sha used in a previous series of experiments belong specifically to the TK-negative or TK-deficient phenotypes: therefore, we further infected animals with an initial parent strain HSV-1/L2 with unchanged drug sensitivity. We would like to emphasize that the ability of TK-deficient and TK-negative strains to cause severe clinical forms of a herpes infection is caused by their natural heterogeneity. The presence of TK-positive virus particles capable of synthesizing functionally active TK in a population allows one to compensate for the lack or a low level of TK activity of ACV-resistant viral particles [32, 32]. The infected animals in experimental groups received Hp-ACG as a triple-distilled water solution as described in Experimental Section. Single doses of Hp- ACG were chosen based on the data on drug efficacy upon i.p. administration in the model of experimental infection in mice caused by HSV-1: the ability of Hp- ACG to protect infected animals from death was 3-4 times lower compared to ACV [18]. Table 2 Influence of orally administered Hp-ACG on the survival rate of BALB/c mice (8.41 ± 0.31 g) infected with HSV-1/L2 Note.The ointment was applied twice daily for 5 days. The first application was 48 hours after infection when a slight redness appeared. The results were registered 4 days after infection. Virus titer in vesicular fluid was determined after 4 days of inoculation when the clinical severity of herpetic manifestations reached their maximum value in the control. The results of two independent experiments are presented. In the case of usage of an ointment of Hp-ACG (5%), the average area of lesions in the experiment was 5.76% lower than in the control (P < 0.05 when evaluated using Student’s t-test) after 2 days (4 days after virus inoculation), while the number of herpetic sores was 95.55% compared to the control (P < 0.3). The term of the start of the reverse process and cure (complete reepithelialization) was decreased by 1 day compared to the control when using a 5% Hp-ACG ointment. The therapeutic effect of Hp-ACG was more pronounced when used as a 10% ointment and also well comparable to the effect of a 5% ACV ointment. A milder clinical course of infection was observed in both cases during the entire period of observation, which was expressed as a decrease in the number of vesicular structures and reduced lesion surface area. The difference between the values obtained in the experimental and control group was statistically significant (P < 0.05 using Student’s t-test). The reverse process and cure of the guinea pigs occurred 1 day earlier than in the control group. The data presented in Table 3 demonstrate that, in all cases, the use of an ointment pharmaceutical form did not lead to a significant reduction in infectious virus titer in vesicular fluid. Therefore, it would be wrong to assume that the ability of Hp-ACG to inhibit the development of a cutaneous herpes infection in guinea pigs caused by a HSV-1/L2 reference strain is due to the inhibition of viral replication at the site of the infection. However, the obtained results are in good agreement with the published data on the influence of ACV upon local administration on infectious titer of HSV under similar experimental conditions. At the same time, a statistically significant decrease in the number of herpetic vesicular formations and a reduction in the lesion surface area were noted [36-38]. Apparently, the effect of Hp-ACG upon local administration has a primarily preventive character, which is expressed in a prevention of the formation of herpetic sores upon drug application during the prodromal phase at the stage of the appearance of a slight redness but not in the inhibition of virus replication in already-formed vesicles. CONCLUSION Thus, our study of the therapeutic efficacy of Hp-ACG action in in vivo experiments revealed that Hp-ACG effectively influences a generalized and cutaneous infection caused by HSV-1upon per os administration or as an ointment pharmaceutical form. Despite the fact that this compound is inferior to ACV (the concentration of Hp-ACG must be increased 2-fold in order to achieve a comparable therapeutic effect), it can inhibit the reproduction of ACV-resistant virus variants, as we have shown in experiments in vitro and in vivo. This makes possible the use of Hp-ACG when ACV is no longer effective.

About the authors

V. L. Andronova

D.I. Ivanovsky Institute of Virology (N.F. Gamaleya Research Center of Epidemiology and Microbiology, Ministry of Healthcare of the Russian Federation)

Author for correspondence.
Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

M. V. Jasko

V.A. Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

M. K. Kukhanova

V.A. Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

G. A. Galegov

V.A. Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

Yu. S. Skoblov

M.M. Shemyakin-Yr.A.Ovchinnikov Institute of Bioorganic Chemistry, Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

S. N. Kochetkov

V.A. Engelhardt Institute of Molecular Biology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: andronova.vl@yandex.ru
Russian Federation

References

Supplementary files